Many people wonder why a doctor would order a MRI over a CT or Xray. In most cases, the reason lies in the differences of information each test or exam can provide and/or the manner it which the test procedure is done.
The biggest difference between an MRI and X-ray is in the manner in which the image is produced. There are no ionizing radiation (the fancy term for X-rays) involved in producing an MRI scan. Instead, MRIs use a strong magnetic field and pulses of radio waves to make images of structures inside the body. So in the broadest or biggest sense, an MRI scan prevents a person from any exposure to X-Rays or any other forms of radiation.
However, that causes another big difference between them both. An MRI may take anywhere from 30 to 60 minutes or more to capture the images. Sometimes even a couple hours in certain circumstances. An X-Ray, however, is somewhat instant compared. Most xrays take around the same time as snapping a picture with your phone or camera. So you could see why in cases such as an emergency, an xray might make more sense.
If a doctor is looking for the most complete information he can get from a test, there is one clear winner - an MRI. Not only can an MRI provide pictures from almost every angle, it can provide a 360 degree view. And, if finding out about a patient's blood vessels are part of the equation, the addition of a contrast given during an MRI can show blood flow and other blood vessel data that no other test can provide, including an xray.
MRIs are very good at identifying legament tears and joint effusions in knee of shoulder injuries. They are also preferred often in the imaging of the spine since both the bones and the spinal cord itself can be evaluated.An MRI can also frequently detect a bone bruise when no crack is visible or hard to see on an X-ray.
Here are two examples to compare:
ABOVE: XRAY of Cervical Spine and Neck.
ABOVE: MRA of blood vessels in neck.
MRIs and CTs are similar in a lot of ways. Both can take about the same amount of prep and time. This link provides a much more detailed list. But in short, these differences stand out the most.
MRI scans are produced in such a way that it is possible to take pictures from almost every angle, whereas a CT scan only shows pictures horizontally. MRI scans give you a more 360 degree view where CT scans are more like very thin slices of bread. In this analogy, think of viewing CT like a loaf of bread if you had one end in front of you and you flipped back the slices one by one, never moving the loaf. Whereas with a MRI, you could hold it up, turn it any way you want, seeing inside of it any way you want. So when it comes to detail, MRIs usually win especially between details such as normal and abnormal tissues.
Like an X-ray, CT scans also use ionizing radiation to produce images. MRIs do not. Basically they use strong magnetic fields and pulses of radio waves. So no radiation with a MRI. However, if any metallic devices or hardware are present in a patient from a past surgury or from other sources, a CT may nned to be ordered in place of an MRI.
Here are two examples to compare:
ABOVE: CT of head taken as slices.
ABOVE: MRI of head in dynamic view.
We would love to hear your thoughts and opinions.
Abdomen • Adrenal Glands • Appendix • Back • Bile Ducts • Bladder • Blood Vessels • Bone • Bowel • Brain • Breast • Cervical Spine • Cervix • Chest • Disc • Fallopian Tube • Fetus • Foot • Full Body • Gallbladder • Head • Heart • Joint • Kidney • Leg • Liver • Lumbar • Lymph Nodes • MRA • Neck • Nose • Overies • Pancreas • Pelvis • Penis • Prostate • Scrotum • Shoulder • Spine • Spleen • Testicles • Tumor • Urethra • Uterus • Vertebrae • Whole Body
IMPORTANT: The information on this page, and throughout the entire site, is not intended to provide advice or treatment for a specific situation. Consult your physician and medical team for information and treatment plans on your specific condition(s). Images are shown for illustrative purposes. Do not attempt to draw conclusions or make diagnoses by comparing these image to other medical images, particularly your own.
More than one million people have already used Two Views to research, compare opinions and learn the facts about healthcare and radiology related topics. It never hurts to get two views.
In 2009 we wondered, why there wasn't a website where you could see different views on the same page? So we created Two Views®. To this day, over 2,000,000 people have visted our site. Read more...
CT and CAT Scans
MRI and MRA Scans
Celebrity Medical Images
Animal Medical Images
Unusual Medical Images
Insane Injury Images
Healthy or Unhealthy?
Wisdom in Two Views